Park Avenue Pizza Company in Waukesha

The prices are way off on 2 different sites. Time to update them. $2.00 more for a fish fry.

Great food, service was slow, waited 30 minutes after order was placed, drinks were good

First time customers, wait was longer than we would have liked for one pizza, but it was fresh and very good.

The waitress was friendly. There wasnt really anyone in the restaurant while eating there but the wait for food was still over 30 minutes. Pizza was subpar, pineapple wasnt ripe.

First time there, for sure going back, excellent fish fry. Next time will be pizza

Fantastic pizza and garlic bread! Service was a little slow, but it was worth it!

Yummy pizza, kind servers, great help. Would greatly recommend this place to anyone.

Had a fantastic pizza Friday night! Crispy and thin crust.called The Company President. Mozzarella, sausage, red onion, green pepper, mushrooms, black olive, and pepperoni. We also enjoyed the beer battered fried mushrooms.

Incredible crispy crust pizza with delicious sauce and no skimping on the toppings.

Top notch fish fry, friendly staff, tasty cocktails. What more could you want on a Friday night.

The band stopped in here after a long day of recording, and we were so glad we did. The pizza here is excellent. Made from scratch. Also, great selection of burgers and pasta.

Usually get takeout, but dined inside... Very nice place. Had appetizer platter #2, it was good and filling... Also had a delicious large pizza... Definitely will return, gotta try the Alfredo and fried chicken 😉

New to the area and looking for a local place. Very tasty and a great crust. I will definitely order again.

Food was good. The wait was long, but be prepared for it as everything is made fresh to order. Theyre very flexible with special request for food as well. One of our party asked for sauteed onions and peppers to be added to their sandwich and the request was accommodated. I overheard another diner request multiple special requests on his pizza. Also accommodated. Nice atmosphere and staff as well.

It was great, A very nice quite place to dine, unlike other restaurants that are to noisy you cant carry on a good conversation at your own table with all the background noise.Also the food is very good and you have a lot of choices and not just pizza. Also the prices are very good for a good meal.

Park Avenue Pizza has the best broastef chicken in the area! Pretty good pizza also! Unhappy that there are no specials during Packets games though; used to go there all of the time to watch the games...

We had the appetizer sampler (#2), broasted chicken dinner, and Alfredo with a California medley soup.I would not get the appetizer sampler again. I think we would’ve been better off trying the toasted ravioli.The soup was fresh and full of veggies. Cheesy base with broccoli, cauliflower, and broccoli.Alfredo was pretty delicious and so was the bread that came with it.Broasted chicken was also delicious and crispy, not overly greasy. I would do without the potato wedges and coleslaw next time.

Cute place, family owned and operated, building has a history. Food is terrific for a pizzeria! You wont be disappointed 🙂

The exterior of the building is unassuming...the interior is a nice vibe offering a bar and dining room. For a pizza place they have the best boasted chicken I have ever had! The thin crust pepperoni pizza was also stellar. Definitely dont pass on place.

I enjoyed my meal when I went here. Got a pizza and some appetizers which were very good. Waitress was very nice and staff were welcoming.

We ordered the Broasted Chicken family meal deal this past Fri. Absolutely delicious! Came with HOT and delicious french fries, rolls and slaw & 10 pieces in a bucket. We also got a lightly breaded fish fri, & house clam Chowder along with the best homemade potato pancakes Ive had! Huge portions and you can taste the love in everything! Best place in Pewaukee to take the entire family. The service is always so great and welcoming. Looking forward to our next meal!

My sister, mom and I stopped by for a pizza and patty melt. Justin was the best server ever! The food was great and the recommended beer was perfect! Thank you Justin for outstanding service!

Lots of mozza, good crust, nice vibe, enjoyed our meal!

Very disappointing experience! There was a miscommunication it seems, I ordered a plain burger with no garnish along with a chicken Parmesan sandwich with no garnish along with chicken noodle soup. Both of the sandwiches came with a pickle and the buns were soaked with pickle juice, the soup was luke warm and the chicken on the chicken Parmesan sandwich was stringy I ended up throwing it away. Now I understand there are bad nights, the part I was the most disappointed with was the manager. I called to share my experience. She talked over me, I couldn’t get a word in edgewise, she blamed me on why the sandwiches were wrong and came with a pickle, made an excuse for the lukewarm soup. Didn’t take any responsibility. She handled the complaint terribly, when I said I wouldn’t be coming back all she could say was ok fine. With businesses fighting to stay open, this is a very sad way to treat your customers.It doesn’t matter how good the food is if the service is lacking.

Nice location. Great menu and friendly staff. Chicken dinner was fantastic and pizza was very good. Glad we made a stop. Will be back

We have always gone for their INCREDIBLE PIZZA.. but decided to try their Fish Fry... it was the best we have had since moving back home 4 years ago...HIGHY RECOMMEND..We added their Haystack Onions for appetizer.. they are recommended as well..Wait staff were friendly and came back to our table a few times to make sure we were happy with the meal..Price was good, and you definitely got your monies worth...We will be back

We stopped in to have a couple of drinks and a pizza. We got a cheese sausage mushroom onion and green pepper and it was delicious! The service was very good as well. I recommend going early or plan on having a drink at the bar while you wait for a table as it is a very popular place and they fill up quickly.

Food is amazing! I dont know what they do to make their pizzas so good, but we make the 40 minute drive, just for their pizza. All their other food is great as well! And the service was perfect. Not constantly checking on you, but also not ignoring you! We highly recommend giving this place a try, it will not disappoint!

Pizza crust was nice and thin/crispy. Sauce was thick and robust, but could have used a little more seasoning. You could tell they get the cheapest pre-shreded, part skim, extremely low moisture mozzarella there is.Garlic bread was an insult to what garlic bread is supposed to be. Its super soft bread with cheese barely melted on top. There was no garlic or any butter on it whatsoever.I personally wouldnt bother going again based solely on the garlic bread.

From pizza, dinner entrees, sandwiches, burgers and fish fry, every meal we have had at Park Avenue Pizza has been perfect. Fried chicken and French Fries are spectacular. Good selection of wine and beers. Very friendly staff who are very conscious of social distancing and safety.

We just had an amazing meal here! Our waitress was AMAZING! If you’re comfortable with going out, please visit them. Our 1 year old had a blast with the staff, as he wandered around.

Amazing food! Had shrimp scampi and French onion soup.

Stop in to get a pizza to go. While waiting for pizza I didn’t order ahead of time decided to try the shredded onion rings. They were very good not greasy at all. You could tell the oil in the deep fryer was fresh no nasty oil flavor. The bartender was exceptional very friendly. I was a executive chef for 30 years and I have to say the pizza was extremely delicious. I would have to say it was the best pizza in Waukesha county. The pizza I ordered was cheese sausage mushroom onion and banana peppers. Right amount of toppings. It was even better then the other pizza place on the other side of the lake

Service was not the best. Food took a long time to come out. Appears there was some kind of disturbance prior to our arrival so things were a little chaotic. They did apologize but for most of the time we were only ones in there. Fish was ok. Used to be excellent. Wont be back for fish. One person in our party had pizza....said it was excellent.

We dined outdoors (53 degrees in June)with our dog and getting used to other people and four-legged friends. Staff was helpful and friendly.The pizza and garlic bread was fantastic.Definitely coming back. Our dog loves the food so much he took half our garlic bread and gives it 5 paws aka stars. He had his own doggie burger which he enthusiastically consumed and also gives it 5 paws.Thank you to the staff who made our evening so much more memorable and entertaining!

This is the second time our whole family of 14 people have gone to Park Avenue Pizza and it has been great! They take reservations, which is appreciated with a big group. With 7 kids it is perfect and the food is very tasty! We will continue to come back!

Great place for Friday night fish. I love the baked fish with potato wedges. Such tasty pizza. Crust was delicious tonight and toppings are always generous. My family loves to meet there to eat and visit.

I went to Park Avenue Pizza for the first time. The pizza was fantastic; however, it took over an hour to get it. Our waitress, who I later found out is a manager, didnt check on us for over 40 minutes. After dinner, I asked to speak to a manager and spoke with the woman who had waited on us. As Id never been there before, I questioned if an hour wait was typical to receive food, especially as they werent particularly busy. She explained that it was not and that this has just been an off night. Had we been informed of this while waiting for dinner, or simply checked on, Id be a bit more understanding but there was absolutely no communication. She suggested we try them again sometime. Given this experience, we dont plan to.

First time Ive had it in a while. Pizza is really good! The supreme is full of flavor and sauce is very unique but delicious. I got to eat this the next day and it was fantastic. I can only imagine It still is just as good fresh!

We went for a late lunch (around 1:30pmand we were the only ones in the place . We ordered a child’s chicken fingers for my daughter while we decided what we wanted. My daughter’s chicken came out fresh and quickly and it was very good. My husband and I ordered a cheese and garlic pizza and it was delicious!!! Super thin and crispy crust and lots of cheese !! Would highly recommend !

While there are scores of good restaurants in Pewaukee, this is our go-to place. Located in an old movie theater, it has a wonderful, homey atmosphere, great food, friendly service, and is always clean. The pizza is truly delicious, and their Tuscan Salad, is my all-time favorite, which is saying a lot, being that Im vegetarian and have eaten thousands of salads! We enjoy the outdoor seating, in the summer, as youre always going to encounter a friend or neighbor, walking by. Lovely place to enjoy an evening cocktail. They are, in fact, so neighbor-friendly, that they even have a guest water bowl for visiting dogs. Go. Enjoy! :D

Cute little place right on the water. Bartenders are always friendly and happy to serve. Food was hot, I ordered a version of a Hawaiian pizza, ham & pineapple, super yummy. The pepperoni pizza is quite spicy, as I have had this in the past. This time we ordered salami instead of pepperoni and the pizza was great. Thus, if you don’t like spicy substitute pepperoni for salami. I will definitely come back.

My family celebrated our grandma’s 88th birthday last Friday. This is my grandma’s favorite place since moving back down to the area. The pizza was good but the service was even better! The young man that waited on our party was very attentive and pleasant. Will definitely visit again.

The pizza is OK. We got the "Company President," and the crust and toppings were good, but the pizza was very over-sauced.We thought pizza would be a nice quick family meal out on a Friday night, but after waiting for our pizza for 45 minutes our toddler was starting to lose it, so we had them bring the pizza put in a to go box. We didnt get an apology or an explanation for the delay.We are in no hurry to go back. There are too many other decent pizza places around town to tolerate slow or poor service.

Delicious thin crust pizza, well known garlic cheese bread, and a selection of craft brews.

My wife and I have been coming to Park Avenue Pizza for about 6 years. We go about 1 to 2 times per week and have never had a bad experience. The food is fantastic whether it is pizza, fish, the best broasted chicken anywhere or anything else on the menu. The family that operates this restaurant are awesome hard working people. The bartenders are friendly and provide excellent service. It is a small operation that sometimes gets busy, but it is worth the wait. I really do not know of a better place to enjoy excellent food and service in the Waukesha area.

Our family has been coming to park avenue for many years. We have always had great service and delicious food. It is family owned and that is the icing In the cake for me and my family. The pizza is our favorite but also love the fish fry and the meatball sub. Have tried many things and loved everything. Their sauce is so good and fresh and ingredients used are fresh too. I would encourage you to try it. You will want to come back again and again

Hard to argue with many other reviews. We usually come in a big group for trivia & always love the food. Reasonable prices. Coupons even help more. Polite servers. But the service is always slow. We just accept that. Seems like ordering to the kitchen to table system is just challenged. Maybe dont have enough staff? Its too bad. I would give 3.5 stars.

I have been here several times for trivia. Every time the service was poor. Last evening was exceptionally poor. From the time we were seated it took 1 hour to get our order taken. That was after asking the wait staff twice to take our order. From the time we ordered to when we got our food was another half hour and the food was barely warm. Had to also ask sevetal times to refill waters too. There was an error on my bill and the waitstaff was very rude to me about it. I dont think I will be going back there. The food is good when it is warm but the waitstaff can make or break a place.

We have been going to Park Avenue Pizza for more then 20 years😃 We have always enjoyed our fish fry, chicken dinners, shrimp dinner, the burger and more! The beer list is outstanding! This family has worked long and hard and because of some family health issues it may at times be trying, but please give them another chance!