Original Italian Pizza in Watertown

I had original wings and pepperoni pizza and was very pleased, especially with the wings! The customer service was wonderful also.

Best pizza ever, seriously.

The best House Pizza up here.

Low end nyc street slice. Weird aftertaste. Overpriced. They dont even bother to heat it up properly before giving it to you. Way better options in town. Avoid.

We got a pizza, Stromboli and wings. The food was delivered on time, hot and SO GOOD! My husband hasnt stopped talking about the wings!

I love the flavor and style, classic NY Style pizza.

Service was very quick. The bread for the sandwich I ordered was outstanding...it made the sandwich great.

the pizza logs are sooooo good ! i would attach a photo but ….. i ate them to quickly and didn’t think about it . yum

$6.50 for literally 20 pieces of fries??? Are you kidding! This shouldn’t be more than $2!!! This is ridiculous.

The grilled wings are excellent. Perfectly crispy.

Great pizza, and amazing wings. Always a favorite to stop by and get a quick bite to eat.

Fresh pizza is sub par, if you get slices they taste very old and stale

Love their subs and wings. I havent had their pizza yet. The only reason I gave 4 stars was that they were a little skimpy on the meat with my cheese steak. It was delicious though.

Im sitting here right now I placed a order two salads 🥗 a stake and cheese sub and 2 plain pizzas I was told they only have one plain pizza I have never been to a pizzeria ever that wouldnt have made another pie thats sorry will never come back plus the place is empty and they are slow as hell this just doesnt make any sense whatsoever. I just wanted to add that its very sad the owner wont respond to the negative reviews like its OK for his place of business to be ran by dirt bags he seems not to care as long as people keep spending money there so sad

Thank you so much for the professionalism and kindness that you all have the atmosphere was welcoming and pleasant the employees are very professional and catering to you will definitely eat here for ever

Amazing pizza staff is great. You can tell this place cares about quality and value customers.

Easy to order online, food was ready even though I was early.Oh yea, it was absolutely delicious too. 👁👄👁

I had a pepperoni pizza and it was pretty good! Perfect amount of sauce, crust and cheese for me. The only thing that would have made it better is if the undercarriage had just a tad bit more crunch to it, but I will definitely come back!

This place has become our "go to" pizza place. Cant go wrong with a XL 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 cheese and a few garlic knots.

We are from Western New York (Buffalowhere there are pizza shops everywhere. OIP is one of the best weve had! Delivery person was friendly. Cant wait to visit Watertown again to have OIP pizza. Maybe well try wings next time as Buffalo is the home of the wing. No pressure OIP.

This pizza was so good to me! Margarita and Meat lovers was in point!

Went in earlier, was welcomed in just before closing to dine in with my family! Our server/cook was I believe named Derek (Derrickhe treated us so kindly, and made sure we were comfortable! Had a hungry 6 year old with us, and food came quick and fresh and DELICIOUS!!!!! Wheelchair accessible also! Thanks again guys. We will see you again soon ❤️❤️❤️

This place has good pizza. The crust is perfect and its not greasy. The fries are good too. The only thing is its expensive!

Ordered pizza, wings, and cheesy bread sticks online and prepaid for the order $56.00!! When my son in law went to pick it up he was told they were out of bread sticks and I would be refunded. That was 4 days ago and Im still waiting on the refund! The pizza crust tasted like frozen dough, the sauce was barely there and tasteless. Overall this place did not live up!! Never againUpdate: Still waiting on that refund and now its over a week! How long does it take OIP?? 🤔🤔

Best pizza and wings I have ever eaten! The staff was very nice and helpful! Definitely worth every penny!

This place has the best pizza in Watertown. The staff is very friendly. Highly recommend you eat there or order for delivery, you wont be disappointed.

The pizza was good, but had to ask for it to be heated s bit longer because it was not hot enough.

Good quality food and service. The parking can get crowded but the food is worth it. The wings taste good but are a little small. The subs, salads and pizzas are where they shine.

OIP Wings are the greatest! Very rarely do you get wings with flavor down to the bone. I challenge anyone to eat these wings and not be tempted to take a bite out of the chicken bone!

Always enjoyed their pizza. They have recently changed to putting tiny bits of onions and peppers on my pizza. Always enjoyed the bigger pieces of toppings! Still will go occasionally, for the price? I prefer a larger selection of toppings!

I just ordered. It was the most nastiest pizza and wings I ever ate and mind y’all I tried dominos wings and pizza.Wings was not cooked at all pink just coming out the wings would NEVER buy again Would post a picture but I threw that food where it goes in the garbage always read the reviews when you gonna order somewhere cause you don’t want to end up like me regretting that you bought from them.

Ordered online for double order wings and had price of $21.99 plus tax for pickup. No extras chosen for celery or bleu cheese. When I arrived for the pickup, I was told different price of $23.99 plus tax. I had email showing the total and questioned why it was different at pickup compared to email confirmation. Response I got was the online system is different than their cashier system and he didn’t know why the price was not changed online. I was not offered to get the price fixed at any point.I explained the online pricing needs to be changed and this should not be put on the customer or other customers ordering online due to two systems not being synced correctly. When I got into my car, the two receipts they gave to me had the different pricing. The food here is always great, but the price difference with my confirmation email compared to paying at pickup seems deceptive.

There services are great, until last night I ordered a cheese an pepperoni calzone and boneless grilled chicken wings for my family and we didnt feel so great through the night. This Morning we all got food poisoning, we dont believe we will be ordering again anytime soon.

I LOVED OIP. mainly because they use to for years give me all flats. About a month ago the stopped doing that so I had to find a new spot 😭😭. However their wings are amazing, the pizza is good as well. Their salad (single serveare HUGE. The salads are good to! The servers there is always friendly. Its good for delivery as well as to sit down and eat. Keep rocking OIP. P.s get your online ordering system working!

Very professional and yummy food .. I would recommend this OIP

The best steak sub I have ever had! Top notch food! Pizza is second to none! Bad reviews are bogus! Best in town! Take a chance! Definitely worth it!

The girl who attended us, very kind good place I recommend the delicious pizzas

I think this is very fair. The wings were sooo good ! Top of the line. The service was minimal, fair at best. We called 15 minutes to close to place our order because we knew they closed at 9 and we were in the area. When we got there 5 minutes later my husband wanted to add a cheesesteak to our order and the cashier told us we couldn’t because the grill was off. That was crazy to me. Turning down business because you want to go home? I see now this happens often. If you can get past the cashier and get there before 830, the wings are a good time!

I went there today during lunch. I ordered the Rigatoni pasta. I requested meatballs with it. After waiting 10 minutes, I first get my garlic knots which was ok followed by salad. From looking at it, it didnt looked fresh. Then came the pasta, the server said they ran out of meatballs. I wished they would have checked first before telling me. I couldve ordered something else instead. So to compensate, they gave me another salad which I told them, I didnt need one. So I asked to just give me another garlic knot. So I tasted the pasta. The rigatoni was not properly cooked. The soda was flat as well. I couldve asked for my refund by left instead unsatisfied. I wouldnt recommend this place.

I had there mild wings and my wife the honey garlic wings. It was in the middle of lunch rush and we had almost no wait time. We had our meal "to-go" and 20 minutes later the wings were still crispy. Cant wait for our second visit! Pizza is next.

Worst customer service Ive ever witnessed at any establishment, especially one that serves food and depends on returning customers. The staff is rude, inconsiderate, unfriendly, no empathy whatsoever. The food is great 4-5 times you order (which is a pretty decent track recordbut when its bad, ITS BAD! Like re-cooked chicken wings my dog wouldnt eat and slimy pizza we threw away. Then they had the audacity to tell me the wings were char-grilled and supposed to be dry, lol. Like I dont know how they tasted the other four times I bought them. They did nothing to remedy the situation which was super discouraging. If youre lucky, the food is great and you should know, its pricey!

Awesome place! Their pizza is good and so are their strombolis!(What you see in the photo). I love their bread and sauce 💕💕💕. Very reasonable prices. Service was nice too. It didnt take long to get our food. I just wished they used basil. Italians cook with basil. 🇮🇹

Food is awesome, but one bad seed can spoil it all. We are new to the area and have only eaten there once. While at the counter, the girl (didn’t get her namerushed us to order and was just all around impatient and not sociable at all. She had an attitude the entire time. Well, here we are calling a week later to see if they delivered and she was just very short-“nope” and hung up right in my face before letting me ask another question. Pretty sure it was the same girl.

Just ordered wings and a pizza deal for 20$ the pizza size is literally a personal pan pizza. It legitimately looks smaller than normal medium pizzas. The wings were 8/10 drums.. I spent a total of 30$ for this order with fries.. Its kind of beat to spend that much for that LITTLE. Good tastes, not a good price for the amount of food you get. Could have just made myself all that for a fraction of the price. Im slightly irritated right now and more so upset. Feel like i just got robbed.

Great food, the wings are high quality and the sauce is crafted in house, unique, 5 star flavor.Female staff is extremely curt. One Star for counter staff/customer service. This was our third visit today (over two monthsevery time the younger female staff displayed a discourteous attitude. Great high quality food (wings, pizza, and cannolis5 stars. One star for staff.

I love this place! I think it’s awesome. Some places close to this one charge ridiculous amounts for pizza that is not even that good. That being said I think their pizza tastes great and is decent price. The grilled wings are something new to me and I was pleasantly surprised. To finish my visit I had the most delicious tasting cannoli I’ve ever tried. I definitely think this place is worth visit and spending money in. A con would be some of the appetizers are too expensive.

I really like their chicken wings. It was $15 for a single order with a fountain drink which I think; is kind of high. Ive tried their pizza and it was good. It is not the same as the pizza; I had in Italy though. It is similar in that it has thin crust.

Good wings. Tried the Mango Habenaronsause. And the Butter Garlic. Some of the staff could be friendlier, and there is no atmosphere, but over all a good experience, will go back.01/30/18- they raised their prices, 10 wings $11.99, a 20 oz fountain soda is $2.00.

Loved this place forever until tonight. On a Saturday night they decide to not deliver my order, make no calls to explain why, and just expect that to be fine. Ive had United China screw up, but they at least called. OIP apparently just thinks its cool to get your card info and not deliver.

Never had a bad pizza from OIP. Food is always ready within minutes of when they say it will be done. Chicken Bacon Ranch is bursting with flavor. Wings are great, you can really taste the flame. Staff is always smiling and helpful.