NY Stromboli Pizza in Allentown

When I order, I usually order a cheeseburger and fries with honey mustard, Im not sure if they changed their cook or management, but the burger had a whole onion slapped on my burger, burnt meat, and bacon, and the bun was hard. The fries tasted like they had salt and they decided it would be a good idea to change their most delicious honey mustard to honey mustard with poppy seed that tastes like chemicals and just plain bad that I cant even eat it at all. I hope they change back to the way they used to be because this is the first time Ive ever been disappointed with their food and Ive been ordering from here for years.

Its a good pizza shop, it can get very busy at times.

The pizza is really good. Ordered a sausage onions peppers parm recently and it was just ok .. lacked enough sausage was still hungry . Prices have gone up as well

Always excellent food and service.

I go here quite often for lunch. The last couple times Ive gone, I noticed one of the guys that makes the pizza in the front checking people out, handling cash and cards with gloves on... he then turns around with the same gloves and handles the food... I saw him take food with his dirty gloves and place it on aluminum foil wrap the food, place it in a box and hand it to a customer... All while I was standing in the front waiting on my food. Nasty!

Pizza is absolutely huge and good quality. Meat lovers was very good.

Perfect prices and really good service but the most important thing is the food the best food in town.

Delicious, crispy, super thin pizza. The garlic knots though... Thats where its at. Little balls of amazingness

Great pizza and garlic knots one of my favorite spots

Freeh AMAZING, pizza without the usual "extra sugar" in the souce, fast and friendly service..

Pizzas, Patties are so delicious! Good price!

I wish theyd open a lil earlierBut I get it. They serve basically luch and Dinner Good pizza Subs Italian Dishes etc. really good prices

The best pizza you can eat in Allentown I guarantee it

They didnt have a chicken slice, a buffalo chicken slice, or a cicilian slice at around 8ish on Thursday, so we got 3 regular slices instead because thats all they had available when we ordered on the phone and they were really thin, too salty and 2 of the slices had thumb marks in them. Very disappointed this time. Not sure what happened because this pizzeria used to serve good pizza...

Very nice small pizza place. Our family got a large meat lovers pizza, garlic knots, cheese fries, and an Italian sandwich (I wasnt in the mood for pizza). I LOVED the appetizers, especially the cheese fries. The portions were also huge, especially for the price they were being sold at. I found it interesting that they didnt use pork products! Overall, I like this place and would recommend it.

My favorite taco pizza!!! Only from NY Stromboli Style Pizza. And for the dessert Im addicted to their cannolis. I love my sweets.

FANTASTIC Pizza and really good prices. I drive out of my way to stop here.

The best pizza 🍕 shop 😋 ever. Their white pizza and wings are perfection. Perfectly cooked with amazing flavor. My go to.

Ordered takeout a couple of times and it was delicious, they’re really quick and friendly and the prices are reasonable. My favorite is chicken Italiano pizza, will definitely come back.

Great customer service, delivery is always hot, fair prices for the size of the pizzas. And the taste? Its a damn good pizza. Stray away from the garlic knots though unless youd eat a raw garlic. Too strong.

Been ordering there for years but lately the food has gotten worst with every order and this will be the last time. Ill be sure to let my friends and family know. Ordered chicken alfredo its basically oily noodles and dry chicken. Comes with a salad they asked for whay dressing, missing 2 salads. I tried contacting them and no answer. Worst customer service as well!!

Food is amazing. I been going here for years

This place is amazing, the food is very good I would recommend the place 50 times over. The portion are huge so what you spend is very well worth it

The pizza is the best, no matter what toppings are on it. The pizza is always hot.

Never had a bad pizza from these guys. Delivery can be a bit slow due to worker shortage, but overall its a great pizza place.

Everyone who worked there is great, very friendly and the place was very cleaned. We went in there sat down and like about 3 seconds they had given us our food. Nice hot and fresh.Also quiet peaceful and relaxing in there too.Yes its worth going to New York Stromboli pizza, they also got some great deals too.

Hadnt been here in awhile but the quality has not changed, its still one of the best pizza places in the area

This pizza is very ordinary. Poor sauce / cheese ratio and the crust is tasteless. Cheese is a high moisture mozzarella which makes it very greasy.

We always enjoy the takeout food here. Really good cheesesteak boli and hot wings. Also excellent garlic knots and pepperoni rolls.

When was the last time you placed a to-go order and not only did it MEET your expectations, it EXCEEDED them? Thats Stromboli. Lunch for 15 and they NAILED IT!! Arrived exactly on time, the order was spot on, driver was communicative and courteous, food was *delish*, and they included a serving utensil for the salad that I had completely overlooked and didnt even ask about. 100% this is our go-to pizza joint from now on. Mille grazie!

Pizza was good but the garlic knots for $35 or 6 of these TINY ONES THAT EQUAL TO 2 normal size knots….. expensive$18 1 pie 1 order of sad knotsDelicioso is Better

I should have not been able to rate this business ! I doubt very much they are from New York because their product is no where near what a true Italian pizza shop serves ! This business is a disgrace to true Italian businesses and should be ashamed of them selves trying to pass as a genuine pasta place . Your a disgrace to defame honorable Italian businesses ! You will be disclosed on social media immediately !!!

Hands down the best spot for pizza, but I always dabble around their menu and order their grill chicken salad. The food here is always fresh & delicious.

This being a “New York pizza” must be a joke. I was visiting Dorney park from New York and was looking for a place to eat but unfortunately this place is below average. Wouldn’t recommend. If this is the best rates pizza in the area I can’t imagine what other places are like. Scary to think.

Only place in the Lehigh Valley that advertises and actually has New York style pizza. So many advertise NY style pizza but it doesn’t have that unique taste. If you’re a New Yorker and new to the area, this is the place to go.

pizza and garlic knots are good but that’s it.if you order a salad it will come delivered with dressing on already making it soggy.and the antipasto salad is so bad. they just throw some slimy lunch meat slices on top, they don’t roll it up and slice it the way it should be. the buffalo chicken pizza is made with red tomato sauce which is not how it should be made.

The best NY style pizza in Lehigh Valley! Amazing size slices, always fresh and delicious. The customer service is amazing. The also have great sub, wings and pasta dishes. I live in the Poconos, everytime Im in town I stop by since 2014.

I can highly recommend the antipasto salad! Everything tasted very fresh, it was loaded with spicy pickled veggies, grated carrots, shredded cabbage, sliced cukes, tomatoes and awesome meats. I had mine without the provolone because I’m lactose intolerant, but I’m sure it would have been delicious. My partner enjoyed the two-slice cheese pizza deal with a small drink. She said it was the best pizza in the Valley. It was a perfect little lunch!

Most Pizza Pizzerias that are outside of NY/NJ that advertise" NY Style Pizza " are generally a BUST, and far removed from true NY Pizzeria taste.Not so here. Its not quite NY, but damn near close. Considering its here in Allentown, I rate em a 9.Yes, the Pizza is good and is evidenced by the constant flow of customers.

Inside is usually crowded. Order delivery, Sometimes it takes a while but overall good pizza. Hoagie arent the greatest and the price of chicken wings are EXPENSIVE!! As of June 20, 2021 until the price of meat goes down Im assuming. Overall its okay.

Best NY style pizza in the Valley by a long shot! Very helpful and family run business with great pizza and Italian food. Ive tried everything from a plain cheese to a Supreme to a chicken parm. Highly recommend and expect it to be busy!

Best pizza place/Italian in the Lehigh Valley. My favorite is the Sicilian pizza, but everything they make is delicious. Lately I’ve been trying the different Italian dinners and they’re all very good. I don’t think you can find better Italian food in the Lehigh Valley. For $11 or $12 I can get two good meals out of one dinner. The owners are hard workers who are almost always on the premises. Place is clean and the service is the best. You won’t be disappointed in this Italian restaurant.

They are always packed inside so you know that means the food is delicious! I Always make it a point to stop here when in the Allentown area. Best pizza iv had since I moved out of Jersey. Yummmm

My favorite pizza in Allentown. Wings are awesome too. Service is always swift but polite. Worth the time and money.Edit: I continue to love their food and service. I order about once a week, food is always great, from the gyro to the cheesesteak, the fettuccine Alfredo with chicken, or the large chicken Caesar salad, their food is always a great value. Need lunch for a few days? Order an entree, like the spaghetti with meat sauce and you are covered.sorry, not sorry, I Love this place.

SKIP THE GARLIC KNOTS. THEY’RE TRASH!I am a fan of Italian food, or fast Italian food LOL. I love garlic bread and garlic knots. So when I ordered my Stromboli’s which were delicious and fair on price. I saw that they have garlic knots, six garlic knots for $3. I was really hungry so I couldn’t wait to get home and decided that it was a good idea to snack on the garlic knots, BAD IDEA!!! The garlic chunks are soooo big they overpowered the taste of bread and any other seasoning. It had a spicy kick to it but the type that only burns your throat. I couldn’t even go for a second bite although I was hungry. Kind of tasted like wasabi to be honest, so if you like wasabi I don’t think you’ll mind the garlic knots. Other than that service was okay, and the Stromboli was good!

Whats not to love about great NY style pizza. The cheese slice is good also tried the sausage. They have the thinly sliced sausages which are delightful on a pizza. Tried their hot wings, when I say huge wings oh man they were on point!! I also love their combo prices which are very decently priced. Small pizza joint but big taste. Have to try their garlic knots next because they look like they pack a punch of flavor too. Check em out!!

Small pizzeria with a good amount seating and friendly staff. The pizza was ok but lacked a bit of flavor. It had a good crust and good amount of cheese.

The NY style pizza is delicious! I typically eat only 1-2 slices, but I couldnt stop eating the pizza!

Placed an order to go. Service was fast and really friendly. Looooved the garlic knots (they use fresh garlic. yum!and pizza! Will def go back.

Not a huge place, but comfy. No table service, but cashier was nice. They have a small variety of pies ready to buy. Prices are good. Sizes are generous. They have free delivery in a 2 miles radio. You can call to place an order.Garlic knots were still a bit cold and had too much garlic for my taste, but the dough was delicious.My pizza was ready really fast. I really liked the cheese and all of the slices were generously full of ingredients. It was a little bit greasy, probably because of the amount of cheese and ingredients.They added garlic on top of the pizza; I like fresh garlic, but I didnt expect it on my pie. I felt like it was overwhelming (more after I had the knots as an appetizer). Unfortunately I couldnt taste the real flavors of the variety I ordered. I dont know if thats something they usually do, but if you dont like or dont want the garlic on your pie, make sure you ask, just in case.I ordered also a cheesecake to go and sadly after I arrived home, noticed that they dont give you any syrup with it, but it was delicious.