Marty's Pizza Pasta & Subs in Waukesha

I love this place. Im glad they reopened!!! Even if it is only for lunch, it works out pretty good because I usually get it once a month for work while at work. Service and food always meets my expectations.

For over a year, I had been suffering from back pain that ran down my leg. Id been to two other chiropractors with no success. My friend suggested I go to Ascent Chiropractic in Brookfield in June 2022. My first visit there left me super impressed. The other chiropractors did not take x-rays, but they did the first visit so they could determine if they could truly help me. Fortunately for me, they could. And now I have much less pain as a result of them. If you have a back or neck problem, they will tell you straight up if they can help you or if you need to see another specialist. 5 STARS!!

Super glad they reopened.🍕It was exciting while we waited for our Pizza.People we coming in hugging, shaking hands and showing true emotions to the owners/staff that they missed them while they were closed 🍕Our pizza order cane up and we took it home to eat. I would have had pictures of how it looked but we ate it so quickly. It was sooooo good. Im buying the next size up next time I come.🇮🇹

Disgusting plain glob of trash…the employees are slow and don’t comprehend how to take the orders right I would never go here to waste my money

Thank you for the many years of great pizza, you will be missed

Great place to have dinner. Been coming by you since the 50s. Good luck.

The zoo and Martys was our 1st date 25 years ago. Sorry we wont have a chance to get back there before it closes.

Hands down the best pizza around! The service was good and the restaurant was very clean.

Say it ain’t so 😭 I heard that you are closing for good. I moved out of state and all I want when I come home is Marty’s!!I have been to at least 20 pizzerias in southern Florida and nothing compares to you! Open shop down here, I will run it!! If not, can you please message me with your sauce recipe at least? 😉

We go every Sunday. The team is awesome. So friendly and Polite they always help me get my mom in and out. Patty has the table ready for us. They do an awesome job!!!

Wonderful staff and scrumptious pizzas! Since about 1.5 years ago, upon discovering Marty’s, it has become our family’s favorite pizza restaurant.

Great pizza. But thats all they serve. So disappointing. Needs to be kept clean a little more. But staff and pizza very good

Its our family tradition to have pizza parties for our birthday celebration and Martys has been the place

Quality and consistency have definitely slipped here. Marty’s was one of the best around but the last few pizzas I’ve ordered from here have been skimpy on the toppings, lacking in sauce with a overly thin dried out crust. They’re still serving pizza only due to lack of help. Seriously? I know the labor market is extremely tight but many other restaurants have been able to overcome the same challenges. I can only guess their employees aren’t compensated appropriately.

It’s ridiculous how their online ordering is never working and then no matter how many months go by, they seem to only be making pizzas. I think It’s time to step up how much you pay people and maybe you’d have a staff.

I’ve been going to Marty’s for a long time now. I remember I used to orders sandwiches from them all the time when I worked at the skate shop. These days I usually get pizza, but I decided to try a calzone. It was HUGE and super delicious!!! Give them a try, you really can’t go wrong.

They shrunk their menu to only pizza and drinks. The pizza was very good. But we missed not having at least garlic bread.

I usually love Martys pizza. I stopped in to get a big one tonight to go and have left-overs. When I got home to eat, I was let-down. The crust is dry and crackery and lacks sauce. I think it may have been the sausage but it seemed to have a lot of kick/red pepper flakes? EDIT-I did call as this was almost $40. I was offered $20 off my next pizza which was good PR!

Been coming here for 50+ years. Still great pizza, great service. No kidding!

Theres a Friday night so we thought it would be busy. We had a group of eight and called on multiple occasions to make sure it was not going to be a problem. Got there and they told us all they were serving was pizza. Would have been good to know when we called the multiple times before coming in.

The pizza was excellent but they only have pizza. No sides or meals. I would have loved some garlic bread.

Great food, great proportions and flavor. Sometimes can get very busy. Havent had an issue on delays. Polite staff. Know it is a chain but still good in my opinion.

Absolutely delicious! Our waitress was also fantastic AND the only one there that evening! She was awesome and her attitude was great too! Love this place 🥰

Pizza is great. They split the family pizza, half cheese, half sausage for us. Not every place will do that anymore. The kids loved that the pizza was the same size as the table.

Amazing service fun waitress and delicious food!! So good!!

Order a $30 pizza. Pizza had no flavor at all! There was hardly any sauce at all. Crust was so hard tou couldnt eat it. After taking my first bite i went up to counter and asked for a side of ranch. Thats another .50cents. Asked for a Togo box and there so cheap they couldnt even give us a big enough one that fit the pizza.. the place was filthy also. Will never again go back there.

Very delicious! We came here instead of another pizza place down the road because they gave us false info for our wait time. So we decided Martys and are very happy we did. Delicious pizza and the staff was very friendly.

Gotta support an iconic place like this. They limit to only pizza some days, but honestly that is what we always get anyway. The pizza is as awesome as ever. I imagine the long time staff there are working as super hard as ever, but it is such an unusual and wonderful thing to see the same faces every time. Tip well!!

The magic is gone. After being a regular customer for 20+ years, I and my family have noticed the pizzas are becoming low quality. We especially noticed the pizzas are shrinking at the corners. A "14 X 19" is more like a 13 X 17 when you see how rounded the corners have become. Additionally, the last 3 pies were partially burned on the bottom to where a "char flavor" resulted. Last year I could accept short comings during the pandemic, but come on, that excuse only lasts so long. They need to price the pizzas to bring loyal customers like me back, or shrink to a third string restaurant like the former Mama Mias before they went out of business.

I’ve been coming here since I was a kid! They have a good selection of pizza but the Margherita pizza in particular is especially good. The game room is typically a nice touch to add to the experience but unfortunately still closed assuming due to covid. They also unfortunately had a limited menu. They also only had one staff member manning the whole dining room. She did a fantastic job but I hope they bring in more help so it’s not all on one persons shoulders. Overall good pizza and a nice place to sit down for the meal or order to go.

Good, but a bit pricey.We were planning to take a pizza to a friend, and decided to get a large "everything" from Martys. We called ahead, and it was ready when they said it would be...and it was good.That said, it was a bit over $27 for just a pizza...nothing else.

I have not been here simce the 70s and I cant believe the building is the same as I remember except a new interior. The pizza - OUTSTANDING and just as good as I remember. Yoy have got to order from this place. Its worth it and way beyond any chain.

Went there with family and was told at door that due to limited staff, they only are serving pizza. This was strange but fine as that is what we came for. 1 server working for all the dine in it seemed but she kept up well. Ordered pizza and cheese garlic bread, something we always get and was a little surprised by the bread. Instead of their usual thicker italien- they used huge slices of sandwich bread and tge butter topping which soaked through bread making it impossible to pick up. They baked it seemed until cheese melted so bread wasnt even toasted and cheese peeled off in attempts to eat. They are truly to pricey to be serving these kind of substitutes in a pinch with no warning.

Great pizza and friendly staff! Will return when in the area.

After being disappointed with another pizza place, I tried this location next. Ordered delivery online. Heres the first complaint about that. In order for you to order online you must first register with Martys. Why is this even here? There should be an "Order as a guest" option. Along with the OPTION to register. This should not be forced onto people. Especially those who are from out of town.Now for the pizza. I ordered there meat pizza. The pepperoni, sausage and Canadian bacon. Along with their cheese curds and tater skins. The pizza tasted great. Good toppings, sauce and crust. Cheese curds were great. Had to wait for the marinara sauce to cool down. It tasted so much better that way. Those tater skins tasted so good.Overall: great pizza, awesome cheese curds and good marinara (when eaten cold). The online ordering needs to be fixed BIG TIME! Please do not force people to register just to order. Especially for people who are out of town passing through. I do like the "call to confirm order" though. Always good to make sure you are dealing with a live person and not a robot.

Been ordering from them for years and never had any problems until now! Ordered a family size pizza for my daughters party and we found a hair. Not just a strand but like 6 pieces of hair in the pizza. Called to tell the manager about it and he didn’t seem to care whatsoever about what happened! Will never order from there again! And he also told me the people that make the pizza don’t wear hair nets only hats. Disgusting! Wont be back ever!

Went in there tonight with my son for dinner. We got seated right away. We were sitting there for about 15 min before we left. There were about 4 different waitresses working in the section we were seated and they all passed us multiple times without acknowledging that we were there or to take our drink order.

Pizza 🍕 is my second favorite food. I love a good tasting pizza. This place was recommended to me. I read the reviews. I like my pizzas brown and crisp! I wasn’t aware that the pizza at Marty’s come cook like that already. My first pizza was burnt. I called the manager and sent pictures. My next pizza was free. I’ve eaten here three times. I’m going to try some of the other menu items as well ! People go here mainly for the pizza!

Fresh tasting veggies cooked to perfection. Delicious, flavorful tomato sauce. Perfect hot temperature from delivery

Got the taco pizza, didnt think it would be any good, but WOW ITS AMAZING. Way to go martys

GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE: I ordered online and choose the wrong topping and didnt notice until the pizza was cooked and I got home. I called as I didnt know yet that this was my mistake. We had amazing customer service, Martys took fault and made me a new pizza. I realized later it was my fault and they were very kind. We will be back!!!

Fantastic homemade square pizzas so people can get more pizza then from a round pie. Been in business since the 1950s and i have been ordering carryout pizza since 2001. Closed on Mondays but otherwise open the rest of the week. If you dont feel like driving to pick it up, their delivery people deliver it to you in their special trucks. During these COVID times, you call ahead, drive to their restaurant when the pizza is ready and they will bring it out to you while you are in the car. My whole family loves Martys!!!

The pizza was awesome, the sub sandwich was amazing and the service was exceptional. However, the Alfredo was dry and uninspired (-1 star). Stick with the pizza and you will not be disappointed.

*Edit*Third time here, we come once a year. Our waitress was fantastic. She took care of us like she was our mother and was super helpful. Sooooo much food especially for the price. I think Ill get 3 meals out of my $11 order.Second time visiting this restaurant and it was delicious. Great value for what you pay and great food! The garlic bread is perfect, not too garlicy and not too crunchy. We made a special trip out of our way for this place because it was so good the first time. And the server was really chill even after I spilled twice. :)

Best pizza, ever! Weve been customers forever. Their pizza is the best. Their sauce is amazing. Garlic bread is way better than Mama Mias. Super value, as priced are insanely low and the quality is great.

Well as you can see from my photos, this was their famous pizza burger🤔🙄😒Ummm... I rather eat school pizza burgers than theirs. Im sure others may like it, but its definitely not my favorite.. I will say their salads are delicious. So some positive came out from that visit.

I love this pizza. Martys has been my all time favorite since childhood. The sauce has great flavor, crust is cooked perfectly, and the toppings are fresh.

Very easy location to get into. Very welcoming and friendly environment. The eggplant and pizzas are really delicious. Great place to enjoy a meal.

Great pizza. A good tasting and solid crust to support the heavy toppings. Dont let the height of the box throw you off, it is a heavy pizza. The veggies are fresh, the sauce ratio is good, and plenty of cheese. I would recommend to others and I will return again myself.

‪Great local pizza spot. The decor is a bit dated, but the wait staff was friendly and attentive and the food was very good. The pizza crust isn’t too thick or thin (it’s just rightand they are quite generous with the toppings. We ordered an XL for 4 adults and barely finished half of it. All in all, great pizza at a very reasonable price. ‬