Lil' Gerardo's in Wheeling

Old school pizza, really good stuff. Staff is great, and their Taco pizza is really good.

Little early to pick up a tray....why was it cold?

By far the best pizza around and great prices

Sauce was very bland, crust wasnt very crispy

No flavor at all! Staff was friendly but the pizza was terrible.

Great Family, Great friendly service and GREAT PIZZA EVERYTIME!! Old school Meatball Hoagies my fav. Oh...and ya NEVER need Xtra cheese! They told me when I first visited, they believe pizza should have "Enough Cheese", without buying more!👍🍕🍕10/10..Square & Round Both🤩🥳

Damn good pizza.

By far the only real pizza joint in America...AND THE OWNERS ARE JUST AS GOOD...

A little piece of nostalgia for me that grew into simply an immaculate restaurant. I went to high school in the area and used to eat this when I was younger because it was available but even as an adult it is still so good. My taste buds have definitely changed but Chicago deep dish and deep fried pepperoni rolls somehow still have the same hold over me as when I was young. If you find yourself craving pizza I wholeheartedly recommend!

Good local pizza!

I got the deep dish pizza and it was without a doubt the best pizza I’ve had in The Valley. You can tell their sauce is made fresh everyday with only the finest ingredients. The crust is baked perfectly and stays consistent even hours after it’s been sitting out. I highly recommend trying out Lil Gerardo’s! Anything you get from there is bomb. Next time I’m getting their meatball sub

Always excellent and they have the greatest staff

Its a very good little family owned business. They have really good food.

Love fast and delicious 9” pie for one person and extra toppings. Late Dinner night.

First time I tried there pizza very good lots of cheese.

Good square pizza

If you’re looking for a pizza that’s more than just a pizza you have found just the place! Regardless of whose on staff, the atmosphere is always fantastic & you’re always served with a smile and respect. It’s a little touch of Italy in our very own little village. The food from all the different varieties of pizzas, pepperoni rolls, or hoagies has immaculate flavor that is endlessly satisfying. If you are looking for a twist on the regular square pizza, then stop in & give this fabulous place a try! The sauce alone will have you coming back thanks to it’s unique flavor background that is just out of this world delicious. Make sure to try an “Old School Pepperoni Roll” if you enjoy a sauce and cheese stuffed pepperoni roll that has been double baked with love & perfection.

Great family operation. Good conversations.Never disappointed in any of the selections we make. Deep Dish Pizza down to the Pepperoni Rolls and Hoagies. You’ll never go wrong with Lil’ Gerardo’s.

Wonderful family owned business that cares about the community and the excellent products that they serve. My first choice every time I return home.

We love the Chicago style pizza!

Great pizza, friendly owners and employees.

BEST PIZZA IN THE VALLEY ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Love the atmosphere when you walk in you are welcomed like family. Great pizza and prices.

If you have tried LilGerardo,s you need to great pizza. I always like the sampler and I here the deep dish is very good

Very friendly family owned pizza shop.Everything there has always been fresh, delicious and correct.Love the fully baked or the deep dish.

Awesome people and awesome food everybody should try it out

The food is unreal! The steak hoagie is to die for and nothing like Ive had before!

The pizza was definitely worth the drive

Awesome pepperoni rolls and pizza

Great service but the pizza was entirely average.

Some of the best Pizza around and reasonable the owner is very nice

Food is very good and the conversation is always good!

Wanted something different for dinner Friday so we ordered the Sampler Pizza. Excellent choice. Perfect for someone that does not eat pizza that often. Was ready for pickup on time and it was hot. What else can you ask for.

Best ever,looking to my next visit.

Dicarlos may have invented pizza by the tray, but there are several pizza shops in the area that do it better, and Lil Gerardos is the best of the bunch.Their other menu items are all delicious, with second to none pepperoni rolls. I frequently visit on Wednesdays when a half tray of pizza, 16 slices, is only $11. They also serve conventional pizza pies.Lil Gerardos is a family run business that has taken a run down corner of the village and vastly improved it. Bellaire is a better place thanks to their hard work. If I have one complaint its that they arent open longer.

I got the Wednesday special. It was a great deal.

Great food, great staff!

Best Pepperoni Rolls in the universe.

Great food and really great people... luv it

The pepperoni rolls are awesome like frizzis but bigger

Live in South Carolina, but my wife has family here. This pizza is incredible. It will become a must stop place every time we come to Ohio.

Good pizza made fast.

Great food and great people. The "old school" pepperoni roll is the best in the valley!!

Delicious food good price and large portions

Great pizza, subs, and pepperoni rolls!

Great Pizza, great staff!

Excellent food. Clean establishment. Friendly people. Simply love it!

Great customer service and good pizza

Good pizza and pepperoni rolls. But my meatball sub I got there before was soggy and rubbery.

Love the pizza and hoagies!!