Kelsey's Pizzeria in Titusville

Super friendly and attentive servers. Food was delicious and portioned well. Prices are very reasonable. Provolone cheese sticks are awesome!

Great placeGreat peopleGreat memoryThe pizza was very good

Great combo pizza and calzone with 4 ingredients - 22$ Fast friendly service and calzone and pizza crust light and crispy, great portions for salads. Will go again!!

Great food, love the dressing for the Greek salad and they don’t skimp on the toppings (aka not lettuce with an olive). It was my first time here but I’ll definitely be back.Also ordered a side of garlic knots and they were super tasty too, with tons of garlic

I was not expecting a deep dish pizza when I ordered my pizza from them it came out so thick it was not enjoyable the crust was sweet the sauce was sweet I sent it back they brought me out some spaghetti marinara so I could eat that it was also so sweet I couldnt even eat it so that is why Im reading it one star

I eat here at least once every time I am in town! The greek salad with thier homemade dressing is the best!!! And the calzones! Yum!

Kelleys has been a go to for 20 plus years for our family. When ever we are back in town we have lunch or dinner here.I highly recommend the Greek salad and their homemade dressing.Service is always great.

Best chicken parmesan and chicken parmesan calzone around!!! Chef salad is great all the food is great at the port st John location

Excellent Pizza! I highly recommend it! The spices and flavor made it mouth watering! The Fettuccine Alfredo tasted basic but, the portion was massive! We were able to share our entrees. The service was good and the employees were friendly!

Be fairly warned, food is always great, but everything is an upcharge. Sandwiches comes with chips, adding fries adds $2. Not bad, just a warning. Food is always great and so is service

We just got home with our dinners, only a 2 mile trip. I tried to cut my eggplant parmigiana and couldnt do it so I looked at it and it was all burnt on the bottom. I called immediately and they said I could get a replacement, but I didnt feel like going back down. I said cant you just mark me in the book for my next trip. They said yes for 15% of my next parmigiana. That is unacceptable. Im old and its hard for me to get around, thats why I didnt go back down.

Overall- fairly disappointing. Fried provolone was good, but pasta was way undercooked. Chicken was inedible. Waitress was not super attentive but the busser kindly refilled our drinks.

Ordered a calzone not much meat. They need to take care of the customers that are coming into the restaurant. Next time I might not go back. There are other business that are willing to go the extra.

We absolutely loved the food. The environment and the service was very good. I would love to come back. We have come from London and felt very welcome by the homely service.

Ive always loved Kelseys. The food is has always been good. They still have decent customer service, so yes I recommend them

Service is slow. Floor is filthy. Dishwasher guy holds handful of silverware barely even washes them. I wont be back. Place has extremely gone downhill.

Port St. John store is the best Kelseys. The cooks there really know their stuff. Keep up the good work

The food was very good. A large portion size for the price. The service was very good.

Service, quality and prices are ALWAYS excellent here. Highly recommended to go eat at.

Great food, great service. We’ve never had issues going here

Great waitress very friendly and attentive to our needs. Food is awsome and always hot.

As always this place is a staple everytime we come to visit top notch pizza,salads,cold brews,and great service.

What is going on there. I just want to give up but they deliver.Greek salad :,no kalmata olives ,no red onion ,no pepperoncini ,green tomatoes instead of red.Mushroom appetizer: mushroom sauce with cheese on top .Gyro: They used to be acceptable here . Not great but acceptable.Meatballs: now they are half the size of a month ago .

Pizza is OK. Not New York style that we prefer. It was still tasty. Will definitely go back and try some italian dishes. Very fair pricing. Looked around and everyone had large portions. Definitely get your monies worth.

Good was incredibly good. Very fresh! Service was pleasant and quick. Portions were large. Definitely impressed.

The best cheese steak in all of Florida. It come with American cheese, so I always exchange it for provolone, but you do it your way. It would be the best with out cheese.at all, cause it is that good. Give yourself a treat.

Was told my order s on its way. Took an hour to get here when I called to inquire about my order the lay laughed at me when I said it better still be hot. What we got w nasty chicken wings a sub that was soggy and half cook fries. Should have called domino’s would have been quicker with eatable food this place us a joke. What a waste of money

This is salami for salad I am confused it is canned spiced spam concoction. They use to serve dry aged salami on chef salad. Sad sad sad

Waited 45 minutes for pizza with the being almost nobody in there and it was under cooked and soggy. Wasnt happy paying full price for bad food.

One of the best pizzas Ive ever eaten in my life the service is fantastic the waitresses are friendly I had a meat lovers with added mushrooms on it it was great

Love this place! Best Kelseys ever! Service is professionally kind and caring with delicious food! One of my favorite places!Pic is; "mini" greek salad that will feed 1 hefty eater or 2 people, with meatball appetizer.....DELICIOUS 😋!

I don’t think I have ever not given a great review for services rendered.After 30+ years of ordering pizza at Kelseys in PSJ, a few months ago the pizza started going in a downward spiral and never improved after multiple attempts. The pizza barely had any toppings on it, the pizza dough was either burnt or undercooked and really was bland and had no taste. I didn’t review the incidents at that time but we decided to no longer order pizza from Kelseys in PSJ.On another note the calzones have been really great, but after multiple attempts last night, we want be ordering the calzones anymore.We ordered 2 #1 calzones and they were delivered in a timely manner. When I opened the styrofoam container one calzones dough was almost completely uncooked dough( I would post the picture, but I can’t find where I can do this). The second calzone was cooked around the edges, but the center was also uncooked dough.I called and spoke to a female who first told me that the pizza dough just looks that way and I explained to her that I have never received a calzone that the dough was undercooked. She then told me I could cook it in the oven. I explained to her that if I had wanted to cook supper I wouldn’t have called them. After multiple excuses for the undercooked dough I told her that I wouldn’t be ordering anything from them anymore and she told me that I didn’t need to get upset about it and they would make it right.She said they would make two more and have them delivered. I told her that I had already waited an hour and she stated that they weren’tbusy and it wouldn’t take that long. So finally two more calzones were delivered and I could only keep one of them because one was a repeat of the other two. I asked if the delivery guy if he could deliver another cooked calzone and he stated he would see what could be done. About a half hour later the delivery person brought us our money back for one calzone and stated that the female said that she wasn’t going to make us another calzone or deal with us anymore. Fortunately for us we at least got one calzone that was cooked completely and our money back on the other. Unfortunately we will not be doing business at Kelseys Pizza in PSJ.Lesson is to check your food before the delivery person leaves your house!!!

We like the meat balls. On keto so dont order pizza, etc. Usually have with roasted spaghetti squash

Best pizza Ive had in a long time! Decent baked ziti as well. The meatballs and sauce are spot on!

We ordered a Philly Cheese Steak that consisted of meat and cheese, where are the onions and peppers? Then the Italian ordered with NO tomatoes and extra oil and vinegar that had tons of tomatoes and no oil and vinegar that could be detected. Very disappointing. Titusville does a much better job.

The bag carrying the food was excellent. The sandwich was lacking butter mayonnaise pickles oops I found a piece of tomatoe. I tried to post 1/4 a star but it wasnt a option.

Love this place. Great pizza and great eggplant parm. Full bar here and $3 margaritas on Wednesday.

They have a wide variety of items on the menu including pasta, pizza, calzones, seafood, wings, etc. We had a small pizza which is indeed very small. Luckily I ordered salads the mini is huge so beware. Its enough for 2. The server was attentive and polite. We got our food fairly quickly. The atmosphere is comfortable. Ill have to come back to try something different.

This was our second time at Kelseys, the pizza was good, I ordered a salad, and I was pleasantly surprised for the generous portion, the mini was more than enough for two people. And our server was very nice and welcoming.

US 1 Port St John; I Figured I’d try them, drive by all the time. Ordered two slices of pepperoni pizza to go. It took 15 minutes and all that had to be done was warm them. Then the price was way too high at more than $8. Slices were small compared to other local restaurants, taste was not very good at all and for length of time, lukewarm. Better option just a few minutes away.

Well after craving the amazing salad they had I ordered it along with pizza knots and chicken noodle soup am I wrong or isn’t there supposed to be chicken in the soup and all my pizza knots were burnt and stuck together after waiting a hour and 15 mins I’m very disappointed

Kelseys has a great turkey greek salad, I have food allergies that dont allow me to enjoy the feta cheese that is usually on the salad, but it is still delicious.

Stopped by after spending the day at Kennedy Space Center. Nice quaint pizzeria friendly staff and good food. Garlic shrimp white pizza is delicious.

Delicious food, but come with an appetite... portions are enormous. The prices are great $$.

Decent pizza for Florida! I was on vacation in the area, our AirB&B was right down the street and we were craving pizza so I decided to get Kelsey’s for carry out. The pizza was very good! Lots of flavor, lots of cheese and cooked perfectly! Garlic knots and garlic bread were also good. Service was prompt and polite for carry out although while I was waiting I heard two different parties complain about the dining room service. One issue was how small the pizzas were, my “large” was the size of a medium in most pizza joints. Prices were a bit high, but normal for a beach tourist area. If I’m ever in the area again, I would go back.

The food is great. I really love this dish of food. So full of herbs and spices. Yummy yum!🎯🤩

Service was great. Each location has a different menu. You will have to seat yourself. The husband had wings. Garlic wings were a miss but the teriyaki were good. The garlic on the wings had no flavor. No seasoning on the wings. My shrimp Carbonara was great. I added ham to mine. I think without the ham, there would not have been enough tomatoes and shrimp. Still could have used more. The kids pizza arrived a little cooled down so they could eat it right away. Overall good experience and would make the drive to this location.

For dinner tonight we went to Kelseys Pizzeria in Port Saint John. Over the past few years we have eaten at several Kelseys locations and have always been quite satisfied. However, tonight it seems that we chose poorly when deciding on our entrees.First impressions are always important and the fact that the menus were worn to the point that the text was smeared and the pages were sticky was not positive. First impressions can be deceiving though, and we thought wed give them a chance.Our meals began with a small house (iceberg lettucesalad, which quite frankly, was unimpressive.My wife had the Eggplant Parmesan. The eggplant was very chewy and tough. She finally had to stop trying to eat it. The server was very nice about it though and offered to take it off the bill, which she did. She also confided that the eggplant was received prebreaded, not prepared on site so the quality was somewhat hit or miss.I had the Seafood Linguine which was very good. However, many of the muscles had broken shells and portions of the shells were scattered throughout the pasta. This made eating my meal a slow and careful process.Both meals were accompanied by garlic bread. I tend to like my garlic bread crispy. This was rather doughy.All in all it probably wasnt the best night for Kelseys. Based on our previous experiences, I am more than willing to give them another opportunity to impress. But not any time soon.

Lots of seating, a large bar area with lots of TVs and good Italian-american comfort food. The mini Greek salad was actually HUGE and delicious. Probably could have made it a meal. Actually, all the portions were huge. Fun family or group place.

If you love Italian food and need huge portions this is the place. Couple minutes drive from the space center, this place should be your choice after a exhausting trip around KSC.As mentioned portions are huge and service is pretty quick. For the money it is really a great place. Loved it, and will visit again if we come to KSC