Fayetteville Pie Company in Fayetteville

Favorite restaurant in Fayetteville. I’ve had over 25 pies over 2 years from this place and they get better every week.

Very delicious gourmet pies on the quick.

I got the chicken pot pie & it was amazing! Pie crust was absolutely lovely and it tasted so good ! Will definitely be going back again !

They have such a fun style of restaurant! There are always some sweet pies and savory pies, and they change daily. I will definitely be back for more!

My first time here. Atmosphere was very relaxed, friendly service. I tried the Athena pie with raspberry and mango for dessert. Amazing!!

Wow, wish we had discovered this sooner on our stay in Fayetteville! Dont miss out! They change their offerings frequently, so theres always something new! The pie crust is to die for! Also, what a beautiful restaurant!

Finally got a chance to try this unique restaurant. Inside is cute how it is set up. I ended up getting 1 savory pie (Earth to Tableand 1 sweet (PD & J). Was a little surprised at the price of the savory pie but was totally worth it. The combination and flavors were very good and had a really good crust. The pie doesnt look very big but it was very filling and to be honest kind of had to force myself to eat the last couple bites...too good to waste. The sweet was also good..was glad they chose strawberry jam instead of the dreaded grape! My only criticism on this pie is I wish the PB flavor of the mousse stood out a little more. Definitely want to try other items when they switch out their menu.

This is a very nice restaurant! The chicken pot pie was delicious! DoRecommend!

Came here for the first time today, will absolutely be back. This place is amazing!!! Very clean and well decorated, the food is delicious and affordable, and plenty of space. What a hidden gem in Fayetteville!

Staff (or maybe owners Im not surewere awesome. They even mentioned other local restaurants for me to visit the next time Im in the area. The place was super clean and tidy. Nothing looked out of place.The food- it was delicious. (Wasnt a fan of the olives on the tacolicious pie, but I pulled them off). Otherwise the savory pie (tacoliciouswas great, and the crust had a perfect texture. Honestly Id happily eat the cust plain, the texture was THAT perfect. The hot chocolate pie was equally as good. I cant wait until Im in the area so I can stop by again (and even though their menu is small, they told me it changes every couple weeks or so, that way they can use only the freshest ingredients). 10/10. Stop here. Enjoy a good meal, and a quiet environment.

I love this place! Whenever friends or family from out of town come to Fayetteville I always bring them here! The same with friends I make who are new to town! This place is on my MUST GO TO list!!!While the desert pies are a personal favorite, the savory pies aren’t to be ignored!

Food was good, but service was awful🤦🏻‍♀️

If you are in Fayetteville, you NEED to eat here. We sometimes even detour this direction because there’s nothing like it closer to home. Such a fun, unique menu that changes daily, and we’ve yet to find a pie we didn’t like!

The pies are interestingly enough pot pies savory and sweet. While I will say pot pie type food is NOT my thing I would suggest you try it.Now it was the customer service and the 80s Music Bingo that will keep me coming back if the continue to do it.This is an inside two story restaurant with a simple menu and very pleasant staff

Ordered and paid for delivery. My order arrives an hour later and they had cancelled my savory pie because they were out of stock, but sent the sweet pie. I would have accepted something else. I paid a stupid amount of money for a $4 pie.

This is the best pie youll ever eat!I love that the flavors are always changing so each time you go is a new experience.The thing that remains constant is that they always taste amazing!I wrote a list of the best places to go for lunch in Fayetteville on my website too if you want more ideas too (website link on my photo)

It was good but the menu is really limited (3 main dishes and 3 desserts). I want to go back and give them another chance.

They were empty and it didnt look like business was booming, but the girls behind the counter were very nice and helpful, and the pies were REALLY GOOD!!!, especially the peach bourbon pie, excellent!!!

Very unique and chic restaurant. They have fresh 3in pies ready for purchase. If you want a full size pie you have to order 24 hours in advance. No problem for me, I just got one of each flavor of the minis.

Fayetteville Pie Company is my go to place for comfort food. Le Pie Mac is TO DIE FOR. The pies are on point and I love that they used locally resourced ingredients. Most people complain about the price without realizing these pies are made with the best ingredients and care! They’re made fresh every day! And to top it off the customer service is always great. FPC will always have my business.

Visited here on Saturday afternoon for the first time. Service was fast, accurate and professional. The staff was friendly and helpful. The food was good. The savory pies were alot better than the sweet pies. I would go back to try other flavors of the savory pies. Maybe it was just the flavors of the sweet pies they had that day that werent great.

Great to try the lunch here, and Ill definitely be picking up some sweet pies for family and friends soon.

Quaint atmosphere. Food was served quickly. The gentleman that was there answered questions we had about the pies as well as which was his favorite. I had the take on a Philly cheese steak. It was very filling and rich in flavor. If you are a cheese fan, try this one. The crust provided a great balance to the rich contents of the pie.Get there before 2. The hours are limited but the food is delish and fresh!

First time customer, and I was impressed. The enchilada pie was phenomenal. The sweet potato pie was okay, but I’m a bit biased - I’ve had some really great down-home sweet potato pies in my lifetime. Maybe if it had been a tad less sweet and included some butter and cream in the filling. Great place!

I was pleasantly surprised at how much I loved their pies! They have a small menu but all the options were so delicious! It was our first time eating here and the staff was patient and helpful as they answered all of our questions! As I said the pies were so good and if we ever come pack to Fayetteville I would love to come back here to eat again!

May 2021Its been a few years since I came here. We were passing through and I decided to revisit. Their pies were still good (some better than others), and the service was decent.I had ordered online ahead of time. When I got there at the indicated time, my order had not been assembled yet. I dont know if this was laziness or because I had ordered all unbaked pies and they didnt have refrigerator space to hold completed orders. Something they should work on. Nevertheless, the staff were friendly and I only had to wait a few minutes for my order to be ready.I really like the Honey BBQ Chicken, sweet and spicy with yummy cornbread. The Shepherds Pie was good, but I dont like how they flavored the meat (exactly how escapes me sadly).Note the cookie crusts for the sweet pies are very thin. I was a little disappointed in the Matcha Pomegranate. They used real matcha, but the flavor was very overpowered by the pomegranate. The Graham Cracker Smacker was very (milkchocolatey with a few mini marshmallows and very thin graham cracker crust.

Stopped in today to try the Carnitas and Cornbread pie, totally not disappointed. So much flavor and so well balanced. Cumin and a little chile in the meat, then the sweet of the cornbread finished with a tangy southwest sauce. The butterscotch in the Lil Punkin was something else as well, but my wife only let me have one bite. I did get to finish the Blueberry Lavender pie though; lots of blueberries, great custardy bottom...check em out, hidden gem when all the breakfast places are packed.

I did not dine in, but the place is very pretty inside, clean and the atmosphere is nice. They have 4 savory pies and 3 or 4 sweet pies in their menu that changes everyday. They are delicious, the price is fair too.I recommend it 100%

Cannot day enough good things about this place. We had the chili con carne pie and the flaming hot Mac and cheese pie for our meals. Our dessert pies were nutter butter and chocolate dulce. The chili and nutter butter pies were the winners but all were fantastic. The staff was attentive and helpful and the restaurant interior is so cute. I hope to be back in Fayetteville so I can eat here again.

First time there today. Pies were excellent. Very filling. Didnt finish the savory because we wanted to have the sweet pies. Wish you were in Sanford. Its a very nice place.

This place is a staple of Fayetteville! Excellent food, creative menu options, and a delightful staff. Before COVID, I would take groups of people there for lunch (we would take up the entire second floor seating areaand we always enjoyed ourselves. Now, they make it easy to “grab and go” with pickup orders. Never been disappointed.

Service was fast and friendly, and the menu was simple and easy to read. I love the clean and cozy feel of this gem. I had a pork and mac&cheese pie- the crust was buttery and delicious and the filling was a hearty balance of both ingredients. The pork was a little salty but worked well with the Mac and cheese.

We used the Fayetteville Pie Company for our rehearsal dinner for our wedding with about 45 guests, renting the space for about 3 hours. We absolutely loved it!!! We were not surprised by how delicious the pies were since we had eaten there before, but we were amazed by the high level of attention and service they offered during our dinner. They served all the food almost at once for all of our guests, which allowed everyone to enjoy food at the same time together. Our guests, of course, raved over the hand-made savory and dessert pies unique to this local restaurant, and also complimented the event space which was decorated in a modern, eclectic style. We have already come back since our wedding to enjoy more pies! :)

•Atmosphere/ Ambiance: 4/5 * Low key, lighting is excellent and so is the location.•Cleanliness: 5/5 *Everything is neat, how they have the hook for the trays is brilliant.• Service: 3/5 * Neutral, not much interaction its pretty much you order and receive. Although, I think the pies are a bit too much. If they were around $8 I would eat there more often. Have you tried making the pies in smaller plates ? Possibly adding a new size for like $6-8. The hours are a little weird.• Food: 4/5 *The Pies are amazing, I wish they had more options during the week.Additional: If I could buy a franchise I would or the company. I have plenty of ideas and may even consider opening something later in life.

YOU WANT TO EAT HERE <3Weve been eating at Fay Pie Co for years, but just last weekend,we had them cater our WEDDING, and to say the pies were a hit would be an understatement. We had Pie Co deliver 5 different versions of their breakfast pies (in the large pie sizefor our morning wedding, hot and ready to eat. Not one person failed to mention how delicious and clever the pies were - and they were all so appreciative of the various options (veggie options, cheesy options, meaty options, etc). After the meal there were at least 20 pies left over from guests who did not show, but by time we went to pack up EVERY SINGLE PIE WAS GONE. Everyone who could took advantage of the unclaimed pies and took some home - they were THAT good.Aside from taste, I need to give a shout out to Leslie and her team for going above and beyond with the customer service. They were prompt with responses and information from the very first time I reached out to them about catering. They came up with a plan that worked for us, and made the entire process easy and seamless. She even checked in with me a couple weeks out, the week of, and the day before the wedding - which as an OCD over-planner I appreciate more than I have the words to express. THANK YOU.If youve never eaten at Pie Co, go fix that now. If you have any catering needs coming up, consider giving Pie Co a call, you wont regret it.

The pies here are so tasty. Some of the savory options may sound daring, but they always taste great. The customer service is always great! They change their menu, which is cool that they change it up and offer different options.

We got married on Pi Day (3.14at the Fayetteville Pie Company and it was better than I could have ever imagined! The location was great for our guests, the food and service was amazing (as usualand the ambiance and decor was beautiful and served as an amazing backdrop for our ceremony and photos. Leslie was great to work with, she clearly explained how it worked to reserve and use the space after hours and she truly made everything so simple and stress-free! The pies were AMAZING, as they always are, they even had vegetarian options available for our guests. It was a great location for our wedding--everything (ceremony and receptionwas done in one place, and we had a great backdrop for our photos and a great ambiance for the whole thing!!! The price for everything was unbeatable, and I would highly recommend The Fayeteville Pie Company, not only for their stellar savory and sweet pies, but also as an event venue--you wont be disappointed!

Must eat place in Fayetteville! You will not be disappointed. The atmosphere is fantastic and the food is made with love; you can taste it! I will definitely be back.

LOOOOOOOVVVVVVVVVVEEEEE this place! I didnt think I was a huge fan of pies until I tried a pie from The Fayetteville Pie Company, and my life was changed---seriously. Ive not had a bad pie here and Im picky! They have a rotating menu so youll never get bored and Ive been able to try something different almost every time I come here. You wont be disappointed, seriously!! Pictured: Colcannon and cherry pie; shepards pie and blueberry swirl; swedish meatball and german chocolate.

The most delicious place in Fayetteville! Each meal includes a savory and sweet pie. I absolutely love the creative savory pies offered each week. You can also order frozen pies to cook at home! A Fayetteville, even NC, must go to for visiting friends and family!The new place is so gorgeous and so much space to sit with great company! There is also great local beer ;)

The food is good, not great. The service is spectacular and the atmosphere is cozy. The negative side is the prices are high for what you get. $14 for a pie and dessert and that doesn’t include a drink.

OMG This place is addictive! The Rhubarb and strawberry pie is one of my favorites.

Food was great!!!! Service was wonderful. Just make sure to come around 1pm. Thats when the crowd starts to die down.

I was able to order offline pick up quickly and the actual restaurant was adorable. Think farmer chic, it was clean and the staff was friendly!

I was pretty charmed by this place. The food came out quick and was very filling. The staff was super friendly.The only drawback is their hours and not very convenient. You only have a small window of time to get there.

Hmm how do I start this. Its a very cozy place, and staff "seems" nice but the pie you get for your money is a joke! $10 for the savory one is way too much, its not a big pie and $4 for a sweet one which is palm size, pretty ridiculous if you ask me. They tasted alright, it didnt blow me away! I had the Carnita & Cornbread well if you say Carnita is in there then I wanna have it and not only find one chunk of meat in there! 😠

I havent had a bad pie yet! They all taste so amazing! I had the apple pie last week and refused to share.

The variety of pies are always changing and they serve them quickly. Always fresh ingredients and they hold up well as a leftover. The workers are always friendly. Not a large location, so if you have a big group takeout might be a better option. Love coming here!

LOVE this place. I just moved to Texas so Im extremely broken hearted that I wont be able to eat Fay Pie Co anymore. They usually have 3 savory and 3 sweet pies to choose from. Its $14 for one of each. Although it may seem pricey, the pies are prepared with care. The ingredients in each are high quality. You can tell the chef is skilled.The inside is a bit small, but they have outdoor seating. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is fun and relaxing. Would recommend.Bring newbies here. Theyll fall in love.

We got a ropa vieja pie and a blueberry lavender pie. Both were sooo good. Im not even really a pie person but the flavors were so good and the crust was flakier than my ex. Just magical. And they were pinterest level cute. Would totally go back to try more flavors.