Clegg's Hotel in Mastic

Overlooking Great South Bay, this relaxed, family-run hotel is 7 minutes' walk from the closest beach, 4 miles from Fire Island lighthouse and 8 miles from Robert Moses State Park.The unassuming, TV-free rooms with quaint decor have shared bathrooms; some rooms offer bay views. Suites sleep up to 4 people, and come with private bathrooms and kitchenettes. Room service is available.Complimentary perks include loaner bikes, beach chairs and umbrellas, and continental breakfast served in a low-key dining room.