• en

Classic Pizza in Petoskey

- View Place Hours
Place Hours
Classic Pizza in Petoskey
4.5
50
Direction

2461 M-88, Central Lake, MI 49622, United States, Petoskey

Ask a question
Description

Classic Pizza - Pizza restaurant in Petoskey, United States

Overview
Features
Review
Add rating:
Classic Pizza
ML
Mary Loper
11.06.2022
5

We’ve had several pizzas from Classic, and almost all have been perfect, but the one we had last week was so delicious, I just need to spread the word! This pizza was perfect. The crust was cooked perfectly, which is hard to do on a deluxe pizza. There was the perfect amount of toppings to sauce ratio. Plenty of cheese! I wish I’d taken a picture, but that pizza just looked too darn good to wait, so we tucked in! I highly recommend Classic Pizza. Give them a try!

Classic Pizza
BC
Brian Caldwell
10.22.2022
5

Thank you. Currently sitting outside enjoying one of the best tasting pizzas Ive had in very long time🙏🤘

Classic Pizza
KW
Kelly Williams
09.22.2022
5

Pizza and bread sticks were delicious!

Classic Pizza
BH
Barry Hackett
09.18.2022
3

Average pizza, barely any tomato sauce, thin crust is not crispy style, just thin and chewy. Ingredients seemed very fresh

Classic Pizza
JB
Joanne B
08.31.2022
5

Fantastic pizza and wonderful customer service! Very small mix up was fixed immediately and with extra kindness. Hands down the BEST gluten free pizza crust I have ever had! My familys regular pizza also was delicious. Very generous with pizza & salad toppings. Some of the tastiest pizza Ive ever had and the owner and employees are all great. Awesome food and experience!

Classic Pizza
Missy
08.07.2022
1

Way to much sauce. Took forever!!!!! All tables were dirty

Classic Pizza
AC
Arielle Castine
07.31.2022
1

Ordered pizza during open hours. Came to pick it up and employees were rude claiming not open, despite door open and 3 people working. Paid money and now have to get that back. Very dissatisfied. Never eating here again.

Classic Pizza
CS
Chris Smith
07.26.2022
5

Food is great. Be prepared to wait.

Classic Pizza
JB
Jenny B
07.16.2022
1

We like the pizza but it seems every time we call they tell us it will be well over an hour. Tried again today and they told us it will be an hour and 45 minutes for the pizza.

Classic Pizza
KP
Karen Prentice
07.11.2022
5

Great pizza and even better pepperoni rolls..delicious!

Classic Pizza
MR
Mike Rossi
07.09.2022
2

Customer service is not their strong suit. Pizza wasnt as hot as other places. Food tasted good, but probably going to stick with Papa Js in the future.

Classic Pizza
JF
Julie Fluger
07.09.2022
1

Nothing like Rinaldis or Fatzos pizza!! Zero stars

Classic Pizza
JC
Jeff Corrion
07.07.2022
5

Classic pizza place, the open sign I swear is always off but theyre always open when I am around.

Classic Pizza
Natron
07.02.2022
5

Great place to enjoy lunch or dinner. Pizza and breadsticks was delicious. Family style local feeling.

Classic Pizza
OM
Olga Makidon
06.27.2022
5

The pizza was fantastic and the service was friendly. We visited this pizzeria several times while visiting Central Lake and the service was consistently great.

Classic Pizza
HS
Hank Stir
06.27.2022
5

Best pizza I have ever had. I recommend the garlic bread with the garlic cream cheese.

Classic Pizza
DS
Doug Stolp
06.13.2022
5

Very good pizza havent tried any thing else yet

Classic Pizza
MH
Mark Hershey
06.12.2022
5

OMG they deliver now, East jordan, elk rapids, bellaire, shanty creek WOW!!Great food, great people working, very nice drivers !

Classic Pizza
JS
Jeanine Schmoldt
06.05.2022
5

Love the food here. Please change away from the ciabatta bread. 😐 way too hard

Classic Pizza
BT
Bear Tron
06.05.2022
4

Overall very satisfied with the pizza that Classic Pizza has to offer.The pizza was well balanced, was not floppy, had decent flavor, slices were huge, and had an adequate amount of sauce.There’s not much to complain about, honestly. The sauce was ok but could be better. A nearly perfect pizza. I almost couldn’t stop eating it. Absolutely will return and I cannot wait to try out more!

Classic Pizza
TT
Truely Treasured
06.04.2022
1

My grandkids wouldnt even eat the pizza. I took a bite and couldnt blame them. And the employees, Im going to be nice about the service and just say your employees are highly undertrained 🙄 and the pile of crust under my sandwich was the cherry on top. I should have listened when i was told to just drive to papa ks. Your employees lost you another local customer tonight.

Classic Pizza
SF
Steve Fry
05.24.2022
5

Very tasty pizza with a friendly staff for service!

Classic Pizza
CK
Cortney Kent
02.16.2022
2

Not impressed with the way that my order was taken over the phone. Felt rushed through the order taking process. When I asked to pay over the phone with my debit card I was blatantly told, "No. Im really busy and dont have time for that. Youll have to pay for it when you come to pick it up". Ive never been refused to pay over the phone by a pizza establishment. When I explained that someone else was picking up the order for me the response was then, "Well I guess I can do that really quick." Couldnt Couldnt finish giving my card information before the person skipped onto asking for expiration date and ended up having to start over. I understand that being a small business is difficult, but customer service can make or break you. 👍

Classic Pizza
JK
James Krout
01.01.2022
4

Food was GREAT!!! Also loved all the names of the different choices. I would definitely recommend eating here..

Classic Pizza
KS
Kyle Schmidt
10.31.2021
5

Great old school pizza place. Nice people, great bread, Ive already recommended it to anyone going up that way.

Classic Pizza
SP
Stephanie Prior
10.24.2021
5

We stopped in for pizza after having a few drinks at Mammoth Distillery, and it was a great experience. Friendly staff, delicious food, and clean! The garlic cheese spread, Ive never had anything like it at any other pizza restaurant. Great spontaneous addition to our date night!

Classic Pizza
BS
BruceAmanda Stuart
09.14.2021
4

Got some subs on house bread. Great for lunch.

Classic Pizza
JM
Justin McAtee
09.07.2021
5

The pizza was delicious! And the salad was much more than the meager pile of romaine and fake cheese youd typically expect from a small town mom-and-pop joint. Our Up North salad was full of walnuts, dried cherries, chocked, and actual greens. Also, the staff was super friendly and gave us advice on places to visit in the area. 5/5

Classic Pizza
AV
Art VanOver
08.26.2021
4

Nice little pizza joint close to Torch Lake. The up north salad was pretty good especially the cherri vinaigrette. We got the roadrunner(meat loverswhich was good but the TBird was delicious. The crust was just right, not too thick and not too thin, and they put a yummy flavoring around the edge. The workers were super friendly also.

Classic Pizza
DM
Drew Mi
08.25.2021
5

A gem of a pizza place with some unique and tasty specialties. Is worth going out of your way to one of their signature creations! Thin crust cooked to perfection, very nice typing selection and great service.

Classic Pizza
RL
R L
07.25.2021
1

Positive reviews must be fake. I am long time customer and used to love classic pizza.Changed ownership a few months ago. Price is up 50% and ingredients down 50%. Won’t go back until it’s “classic” again.Place will tank once the post COVID rush is over

Classic Pizza
JS
Jamie Scholl
07.19.2021
3

Wow! This place was hopping. My call for ordering responded timely and accurately. Four young kids busting it out. Restraunt portion very clean and welcoming. As I picked up the Grinder , the staff was awesome. I ordered the Italian and it was spot on otherthen the pile of lettuce they jammed into it due to the rush.It was a little toasted past my taste but otherwise good. Back up help was not available and heard one customers complain for minimal reasons. I recommend being specific on what you order maybe even writing it down to give them. Owners needed better management and cleaner kitchen. Thecashier needed to be more vocal on what she needed from her staff and these kids need bonuses on days like these!

Classic Pizza
LC
L Chapman
07.17.2021
4

Pretty good pizza, but the dough is a little tough. The cheese bread sticks are really good. Not bad for the small selection of food in Central Lake. We ate it!!

Classic Pizza
TS
Tara Steimel
06.28.2021
5

Classic pizza did not disappoint on our summer woman’s weekend! Blt, supreme, taco, Hawaiian pizza’s, cheese bread with yummy garlic cream cheese spread was our order. All wonderful for dinner and left overs for the next day! So worth the wait. Cute little town and great service. Thank you for helping make 8 woman’s weekend one to remember!

Classic Pizza
KW
Kathy Wahl
06.24.2021
5

We ordered a medium pizza (14"with 4 extra toppings. It was delicious. It was ready and very hot when I picked it up. We will definitely be getting more from Classic Pizza.

Classic Pizza
MD
Mistri Danigami
08.24.2020
5

This is the best place to eat in this small town. i get it alot, the food is amazing for the price. i suggest that if your looking for something by yourself and you want left overs get a pizza or calzone. if your looking for something quick and easy get the hamburger or some sort of sandwich or medium pizza that will fill you up but with the pizza you will have minimum leftovers and keep in mind that this is a family owned business so the food is real and service while it can be slow if busy but the service is usually fast. i would give this ten stars if i could!

Classic Pizza
gc
graham cracker
07.28.2020
5

The pizza is truly amazing. It is one of the best Ive ever had. Would definitely order from there again.

Classic Pizza
MR
Michael Rabaduex
02.17.2020
5

Good pizza. I will be going back. We got the bbq chicken pizza.

Classic Pizza
KJ
Kimberly Jolly
09.08.2019
5

We stopped in after our son’s football game!! We had a little travel! About 2 hours!, but what a nice travel!!! Great small little friendly town! Food was great!! Had lots of left overs!! And still the same great taste!!

Classic Pizza
DZ
David Z
09.02.2019
5

My wife and I stopped out of the blue. They have amazing tasting food.I had the Italian sub an she had the steak.Just the bread alone was awesome!If ever in the area again. We would most definitely visit again. Thank you

Classic Pizza
JK
John K. Fitzgerald jr.
08.10.2019
4

From out of state.A great local pizzeria with good prices and satisfying food. Pizza is quite greasy but there is a roll of paper towels at each table just for that reason so dab away. A good place to go after spending the day on the lake.

Classic Pizza
LB
Lynn Brown
07.24.2019
1

My husband and I love pizza. This pizza was so delicious!!! I only had one problem...the service was blatantly rude. My husband and I watched as a family came in after us and got the full service with a smile treatment from both women. We were barely spoken to and felt unwelcome. I even mentioned that it was our first time there. You’d think that they’d want to leave a good impression. Unfortunately, we will not be returning there.

Classic Pizza
DR
Dee Railya
07.20.2019
5

Clean restaurant, delicious food, and friendly staff. Everyone loved the pizza, the chef salad was AMAZING, and the loaded potato wedges were outstanding. We will definitely be back more often.

Classic Pizza
DC
Dan Clan Russell
05.18.2019
4

Food was good.. pizza was good.. our bill totaled right under $40. We had a large road runner $19 and some change, bread sticks just under $5 and 2 salad buffets (just your basic veges and toppingsboth just under $10. And a heads up, if your using a card to pay and not purchasing a sandwich, I was told its $5. beverage options were fountain pop, fountain tea or fountain water.

Classic Pizza
CH
Chris Hoekstra
09.14.2018
4

A small town pizzeria. There are about 10 tables inside. They have a very extensive menu.Ive had their pizza before, and it is good. However I wasnt in the mood for pizza. So I ordered a pulled pork sandwich, some mac n cheese, and a small onion rings. The Sandwich was good but ovet priced. It wasnt an $8 or $9 dollar sandwich, more like $5 or $6. Still good though. The Mac was a little soupy which worried me, however it tasted excellent. Lastly the onion rings were good, nothing special, but still very good.Overall a solid 4 stars. Would I return? Yes I will.

Classic Pizza
RW
Rich Williams
03.24.2018
5

Came up to Central Lake with Family and took them to one of our favorite pizza places, Classic Pizza. Ordered the veggie, hot wings, salad and a green olive and pepperoni pizza. Once again it was fantastic and our family really enjoyed their the food. If you are in the area some stop by ad take in a slice.

Classic Pizza
BP
Bill Porta
07.06.2017
1

Not sure if anyone who has posted here actually has had a "good" pizza, but this wasnt it... greasy, soggy, and in my opinion not worth the $13. Was a little taken back when I watched them carry 10-15 pre-rolled pizza dough individually wrapped and stacked in cellophane. Havent tried anything else on the menu, not sure I want to though...

Classic Pizza
BR
Bev Reid (Bevtypesfast)
09.21.2016
4

very nice people who work hard to provide great pizza! Great for that "I-dont-feel-like-cooking" night. (Thats every night, right? Try them...great food for reasonable price. Dont forget to tip them!

Classic Pizza
JR
James Rashilla
07.07.2016
5

Fantastic pizza and calzones for excellent prices. The place is decorated with models of classic cars, which is great for the kids in your group. Order at the counter and theyll bring your food out to you.

Classic Pizza
LC
Larry C
11.30.2013
5

Consistently very good pizza; have always received exactly what was ordered. Toppings are great and generous.Grinders are great (about the best weve had anywhere- terrific bread.Calzones are terrific as well.About the only complaint is that the amount of toppings on the pizza (or stuff in the calzones, or meat, etc. on the grindersis close to excessive (actually might be too much sometimes). Not a real complaint, just makes eating a little messy sometimes!

Phone
View number phone +1 231-544-5555
Last update: {date}
4.5
50
Open
Classic Pizza in Petoskey

2461 M-88, Central Lake, MI 49622, United States, Petoskey

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!